A Dream Realized, A Mission to Define
Daniel R. Bernard looks at the challenges and hopes
surrounding the opening of the Bibliotheca
Alexandrina
As AUC undertakes the challenge of
building a new state-of-the-art campus to elevate scholarship in
Egypt and build bridges between cultures, it is not alone. After
decades of effort by local organizers, the Egyptian government and
international supporters, the glittering Bibliotheca Alexandrina
promises to be an invaluable ally in the mission of scholarly
research and intercultural understanding. First Lady Suzanne Mubarak
'77, '82, chair of the library's board of trustees, describes it as
"Egypt's window on the world and the world's window on Egypt."

If it could be
said that the ancient Library of Alexandria became a ghost after the
building was destroyed by fire in 48 B.C., it now has a new body to
occupy. The ultramodern structure of the new Bibliotheca Alexandrina
is now a unique landmark on the Mediterranean coast. But before the
spirit of that history-changing archive can imbue the new building,
organizers are going to have to work hard to show that the new
institution can change the world too.
In the three
decades that moved it from implausible dream to granite reality, the
resurrected Bibliotheca Alexandrina assumed many potential roles.
The striking architecture instantly made it the pride of resurgent
Alexandria, while its army of benefactors ensured that it had the
potential to become a significant treasury of international printed
materials. Supporters, however, hope that the library will become
much more: a prestigious center of scholarly research, a
front-runner in computerized information storage, a host to major
international academic conferences, a goodwill ambassador for Egypt
and a mediator in the clash of civilizations.
But even as
organizers celebrate having overcome daunting financial and
logistical hurdles, the commemorations mark challenges of identity
for the new Bibliotheca Alexandrina. With such sprawling ambitions,
what kind of library will it be? If the institution aspires to be
authoritative in academic research, what will be its niche? More
pragmatically, while the library aspires to hold four to eight
million documents, its shelves currently hold about a quarter of a
million books. How can a library in the expensive 21st century catch
up with institutions that have been gathering materials for hundreds
of years? Defining these missions and securing the means will be the
challenge of the international scholars, who comprise the
Bibliotheca's new board of trustees, and of its director, Dr. Ismail
Serageldin, former vice president of the World Bank.
"When I met the
director of the Library of Congress, Daniel Boorstin," says Moustafa
El-Abbadi, a father of the revival project, "he said, 'Good heavens,
you are dreamers. You want to construct a universal library at the
end of the 20th century? We could not replicate the Library of
Congress at the end of the 20th century.' I said, 'Yes, I know, but
we have to move.'"
Spectacular Vessel
While the mission and
function of the library have yet to solidify, the facility's
physical shape is nothing short of triumphant. The most distinctive
element of Alexandria's skyline looks like it could be the ceramic
bowl of a giant, tipped to one side. The library's round perimeter
wall is made of granite from Aswan and engraved with letters and
symbols from every known system of writing. Around it are shallow
reflecting pools. The building's roof is slanted in such a way that
it becomes the faŤade, making it seem as if the building is peering
out at the sea. The library's architects, from the Norwegian firm
Snohetta, say the slant is intended to echo the sun meeting the
horizon, symbolizing the passage of time. The angle also maximizes
natural light and, in a faint echo of a pyramid, makes each upper
floor smaller than the one below it.
At the lowest level, the
largest floor will hold manuscripts and rare books. The library
already has more than 10,000 and has begun digitizing the
manuscripts for electronic display and translation. Above are areas
for multimedia, language and literature, and then music, art and
architecture. The United Nations and European Union have made
Alexandria one of the official depository libraries for their
publications, which are housed on the fourth floor, along with labs
for film and paper conservation. Sections for the blind and for
children are on the fifth and sixth floors. The next two floors are
reserved for the International School for Information Studies, not
expected to be a degree-conferring institution but envisioned as a
home for leading-edge research in the computerized storage of
knowledge. The two narrowest floors at the peak are for
administration.
The outer edge
of the library is intersected by a long walkway that extends to the
University of Alexandria in one direction and to the Corniche on the
other. At the street side of the 45,000-square meter property, the
promenade passes the library's planetarium and science museum, a
smaller sphere with illuminated stripes that make it look like a
cosmic croquet ball. A 3,200-capacity conference center completes
the site.

Storied Site
The new Bibliotheca
Alexandrina is located on the same site, give or take a kilometer,
where the ancient library was built 2,300 years earlier. Alexander
the Great conquered the known world and thought about amassing the
world's knowledge in the city that he founded in his name. But the
Great Library was born later, under Ptolemy I Soter, the Greek king
of Egypt who asserted independence from the empire and made
Alexandria the seat of his kingdom and a world center for
scholarship.
Ptolemy ordered the library built in 295 B.C. and
sent emissaries to collect scrolls under an aggressive program
continued by his son Ptolemy II Philadelphus and grandson, Ptolemy
III Euergetes. Soter gave his chief librarian, Demetrius, a generous
budget and encouraged him to acquire all the books in the world. As
recounted in Moustafa El-Abbadi's history of the library, when Soter
asked how many books had been gathered, Demetrius replied: "More
than two hundred thousand, O King; and I will soon make diligent
search for the remainder, so that a total of half a million may be
reached."
These were
bibliophiles with guile. The Ptolemies reportedly searched ships
unloading in the Alexandria harbor for scrolls, taking the ones
deemed desirable and compensating the owners. El-Abbadi tells the
story of how Ptolemy III persuaded Athens to lend him the
manuscripts of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides so that he could
copy them, only to send back the copies and keep the originals in
Alexandria. Such insistent methods eventually increased the
library's collection to an estimated 500,000 scrolls.
Meanwhile, the
library became the magnet for an elevated center of scholarship-the
"Mouseion" or shrine to the Muses, where leading minds would come to
study and teach elite groups of pupils. It was there that Archimedes
invented his pump and Euclid wrote the foundations of geometry;
there that other scholars determined the function of the heart,
devised the leap year, and estimated the Earth's circumference. A
newly published book, The Library of Alexandria: Center of Learning
in the Ancient World (The AUC Press), contends that the library
caused a convergence between cultures as it drew together scholars
and statesmen from Greek, Roman, Jewish and Syrian
societies.
But the rise of
the Roman Empire led to the library's undoing. In 48 B.C., Julius
Caesar, siding with Cleopatra in her war with her younger brother
Ptolemy XIII, found himself boxed in at Alexandria. As a tactical
maneuver, he set fire to the ships in the harbor. The Great Library,
adjacent to the harbor, is believed to have been destroyed along
with 40,000 scrolls, perhaps many more. Part of the collection
remained unscathed at smaller libraries and the Mouseion, where
teaching and scientific research continued after the Romans
conquered Egypt in 30 B.C. But Roman suppression of rebellions in
the 3rd century A.D. scared away the scholars, and it is believed
that the Mouseion was destroyed in 391 A.D. by Roman
decree.
Through time, as
Roman dominion passed to Arabs, Ottomans, colonialism and
independence, the Library of Alexandria was no more a candidate for
resurrection than the lost city of Atlantis.
A School With No Library
Success has
many fathers, and the new Bibliotheca Alexandrina has at least two.
Dr. Lutfi Dowidar, an Alexandria native, traveled to Cairo
University for his medical degree and stayed on as a lecturer in the
medical school. In 1945, he came back to be part of Alexandria
University, formed three years earlier. Amid wartime scarcity, the
school's founders put a priority on the essentials-classroom
buildings, instructors' offices and labs. Compared to Cairo, "it was
clear to me what was missing in the university," says Dowidar,
namely, a large library, not to mention a conference
center.
Dr. Moustafa
El-Abbadi grew up in Alexandria and attended its university,
becoming a professor of ancient history there in 1960 after
completing his studies at Cambridge University. In 1972, at a public
lecture at the university's faculty club, El-Abbadi suggested that a
new library for the university could be built as a revival of the
ancient institution. Encouraged by Dowidar, the university's
director at the time, El-Abbadi wrote a paper in 1974 elaborating on
the proposal. The two served on committees to study the idea and
found another key supporter in the late Fouad Helmy, a professor of
civil engineering and onetime Alexandria governor.
The response in
Alexandria and Cairo was unanimous: Great idea, but too expensive,
especially in the aftermath of the 1973 war. "The idea was in our
minds and on paper, but nothing moved," says Dowidar, who later
became president of Alexandria University. For a while, the idea
stalled.
As Egypt's
financial situation improved, the government adopted the project as
a priority, but money was still lacking. In 1984, organizers decided
they needed help on a global scale. Alexandria organizers sent
proposals and delegates to the United Nations Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), which had shown its
effectiveness in preserving Egyptian heritage with massive projects
such as the relocation of the giant Ramses II temples at Abu
Simbel.
In 1986, then
UNESCO Director-General Amadou-Mahtar M'Bow of Senegal visited
Alexandria, and organizers say that his visit was the crucial
turning point. M'Bow was enthralled with the idea and agreed to put
UNESCO's organizing powers and fundraising reach behind the
project-under two conditions. First, because UNESCO makes agreements
with governments, not universities, the library would be identified
as one for the public and not the university community. Second, to
emphasize that the project was intended as a revival of ancient
Greek roots, the new project would go by the name Bibliotheca
Alexandrina. "Then the whole world started to hear about it,"
Dowidar points out. "Without UNESCO, the project could never have
seen the light."
In 1987, M'Bow
issued an appeal for international assistance. In 1990, First Lady
Suzanne Mubarak hosted leaders from 17 countries as they signed the
Aswan Declaration pledging their support for the project and calling
for donations. The declaration could scarcely have been more
ambitious: "The Bibliotheca Alexandrina will stand as a testimony to
a decisive moment in the history of human thought ... It will bear
witness to an original undertaking that, in embracing the totality
and diversity of human experience, became the matrix for a new
spirit of critical inquiry, for a heightened perception of knowledge
as a collaborative process."
Associations of
Friends of the Alexandria Library formed around the world to gather
funds and books. Arab countries donated $65 million, while 27 other
countries contributed $32 million. In addition to donating the land
and the recently constructed conference center, Egypt pledged $120
million over the life of the project. Construction began in
1995.

Many Missions
The library project
rapidly took on Egypt's aspirations to be a leader not only in
scholarship but also in solving contemporary problems and mending
rifts between different segments of civilization.
"The Library of
Alexandria not only focuses on ancient knowledge and future science,
but also concentrates on the present, which abounds with inspiration
and creativity," Mrs. Mubarak said in a speech at the library's soft
opening just weeks after the September 11 terrorist attacks. "The
library will be Egypt's window on the world and the world's window
on Egypt. It will be a meeting point for dialogue between ideas and
cultures, an openness that we desperately need at this time,
especially after the tragic events the world has recently
witnessed."
The visions have
been articulated by Mrs. Mubarak, who headed the international
commission for the project and now chairs the library's board of
trustees, and by Ismail Serageldin, the World Bank official who
advised the Egyptian government on the project and was named its
first director. Serageldin, who headed the international jury that
selected a master planner for AUC's move from central Cairo to a
planned community near Heliopolis, received an honorary doctor of
humane letters degree from AUC in June 2000 and was a distinguished
visiting professor at AUC in 2000-01. Before President Hosni Mubarak
named him director of the Alexandria Library, he was under
consideration for the post of UNESCO
director-general.
Serageldin has
said that he wants the library to be a leader in technology and
intellectual debate, even on the thorniest modern issues. "We have
chosen as the focus the ethics of science of technology, an area of
enormous importance with every single discovery, every day. There is
no [library] you immediately think of where you go for that," he
told AUCtoday.
The ambitions
are broad, but Serageldin's experience and personal drive make them
realistic. "He is a very dynamic person with an international
dimension," says Richard Holmquist, UNESCO's liaison to the project.
"By virtue of his dynamism and leadership, [his appointment] is a
key element."
Establishing a
new meeting place for the world will take time, but the library is
beginning to fill in its calendar. A conference on biotechnology
took place in March under the auspices of the United Nations Food
and Agriculture Organization, the Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development and others. In September 2002, the
International Labor Organization and the Organization of American
States are expected to hold the Youth Employment
Conference.
Finding A Research Niche
The Bibliotheca
Alexandrina is committed to the goal of increasing human knowledge,
but still undefined is what field the library will establish itself
in as an essential stop for researchers. "It must be specialized in
something. Otherwise it will have no meaning," says former
Alexandria University President Dowidar. Dowidar believes the
Bibliotheca Alexandrina's research specialties should draw on the
fields that spring naturally from its place in an historic and
desert land: the early civilizations of the Middle East, the
Mediterranean region and even elsewhere in Africa and the Far East;
Islam and the roots of Christianity and Judaism; and agriculture,
irrigation and related sciences.
But the past is
not enough, says Dr. Laila Takla, a former member of Egypt's
parliament and onetime AUC professor, who serves on the library's
board of trustees. Takla agrees that the library should specialize
in scholarship of ancient civilizations and religions. In fact, with
rare book donations flowing in from Egypt's Coptic and Jewish
leaders, the library may follow Mrs. Mubarak's suggestion of adding
a "hall of religions." But Takla hopes the library will develop
renown for following the ancient disciplines through their evolution
to the present. "It's not only historical. We will never forget
today and tomorrow," says Takla.
The trustees'
policies in coming years will point the way. Serageldin favors
specializing in technology and science, in particular behavioral
sciences, because those studies fuel many current debates and
currently lack a dominant research library, says the library's media
consultant Khaled Azab.
Then there is
the bedrock challenge of any new library: filling the shelves. While
the Aswan Declaration proclaimed that the Bibliotheca Alexandrina
would "attempt to constitute a summum of knowledge, to assemble the
writings of all the peoples," organizers are not attempting to race
to universal library status. Money is still an issue. While Egypt is
expecting to cover the ongoing operations with help from donations
and library fees, UNESCO officials, acknowledging that Egypt may
need help with the day-to-day budget over the long term, have
continued fundraising for operating expenses. Serageldin has said
that he hopes the library's annual acquisition budget in the next
few years will grow to more than $1 million, even $2 million, but in
targeted areas. "Clearly, the competitive advantage is not going to
be in the sheer number of volumes that are available," Serageldin
says. "We have to have a very focused strategy in our collection.
There are some things where we can become the very best in the
world."
Far from the
Ptolemaic approach of ordering aides far and wide on search-and-grab
book expeditions, the current library's policy will be to start
locally and spread: first gathering enough material to become
authoritative on Alexandria, then on Egypt as a whole, and then on
the Mediterranean region and Arab world, while taking care not to
duplicate the work of already existing pan-Arab archives. As for
subjects, Serageldin wants the book acquisitions to concentrate on a
group of disciplines: science and technology, including ethical
issues; humanities, including the ancient Greeks; arts and culture;
and development issues including water use. "From out of that
matrix, you begin to see, if we want the library to be a vibrant
center of intellectual debate, then we can pick things that fit into
that," Serageldin says. "And at the same time we use that template
to have a collection strategy for our books and periodicals before
jumping forward to the electronic age and bringing our history to
life."
"How will we do
it? What are the areas of our priority? These questions cannot be
answered at this point. These are all things that will have to be
studied, and we will study them," states Takla.
For Serageldin,
the high expectations of the library are a sign of the high public
support and interest in the project. He says the institution would
have to defer on some aspirations in order to excel in several. "It
will take a little bit of time for people to sort out their
expectations, because some people expect things that the library
shouldn't do," Serageldin says. "Organizing scientific research is
not the responsibility of the library. Neither is doing what the
Ministry of Culture already does. People project certain things on
the library that are not realistic. But after a while of sticking to
a clear set of priorities and linking our activities in terms of
scholarship with the shows that we organize and the conferences, we
hope we'll gradually establish a persona for the library."
As impossible as
it is to bring the ancient Library of Alexandria back to life, the
follow-through could be almost as challenging. At the core, the old
and new share the goal of increasing humanity's collective
understanding. By gathering the writings and scholars of all
nations, the Great Library made possible a turning point in human
science. The Bibliotheca Alexandrina today vows to foster dialogues
that will offer solutions to pressing current problems."It's not a
copy of the old library, but it gets its inspiration from the old
library," says Holmquist.
"It's a revival
of an idea," says El-Abbadi, "not of a building."
For more
information on the Bibliotheca Alexandrina, go to http://www.bibalex.org/
Related:
Recapturing
the Spirit
If the Library of Alexandria is to reach the
stature of its ancient namesake, the burden lies most squarely on
its director, Dr. Ismail
Serageldin